Reading Labels

This piece resulted from a SprayPass committee meeting. It is the writers opinion only. ( but it is an awfully good opinion )

It is nigh on impossible for manufacturers or regulators to foretell every eventuality that may occur in the field.

Labels come in two bits. The bit that is stuck on the drum and the removeable booklet, hereafter called the label. They are there because of a statutory Act which say’s they have to be, and the same Act also regulates the format & content right down to the size of the font. It is overseen by APVMA. ( the format is common across Aus.)

Labels are rapidly becoming two bit documents, the manufactures bit and the regulators bit. This is mainly about the manufactures bit. Labels are risk based so they have a degree of reality. Firstly there are the signal headings which indicate the range of toxicity of the product. That’s good to know. There is also information about withholding & slaughter intervals which is to do with human health via the food chain.

Labels change over time and regulators have also stepped in and made certain aspects of use mandatory. It is an offence to ignore any sentence with the words DO NOT in upper case.

If you have done or do a chemical user course, the trainers will explain the ” correct interpretation” of the label. They’ll also tell you, quite correctly, that the label is a legal document. This is said however to frighten you into not questioning what they are saying or anything on the label.  Like wondering what type of legal document it is ? Well accordiong to the label it is a warranty, & a limited one at that.

The reality is that labels are, almost unavoidably, ambiguous !

Some is subjective, including some of the prosecutable parts. Is there some measurement of plant stress? What is a prolonged time?

Some information is based on assumtions. Some labels assume that handgun application is at 1000 lt/ha. Others say spray to the point of runoff. The difference being a mere 2-3000 lts.

Sometimes the numbers don’t stack up. Boom rate of 60g/ha and handgun rate of 10g/100 lt for the same product. Even at 1000 lt/ha, that equals 100g/ha. ( there is no direct comparision between boom & handgun.)

Some is amusing. Like the comedians who suggest using a handgun at 10 bar. (150 psi )

Most label rates are based around the optimum stage of growth but once a pest has got beyond that stage, ( when contractors are called in ),choosing a rate is a bit like ‘pick a box’. Not all labels are the same for what is effectively the same product, often due to marketing. e,g, not all glyphosate products have serrated tussock on the label because some manufactures don’t see it as much of a market so no info on the label. There is a lot more valuable information in the following label subheadings.

General instructions, mixing information, spaying volumes, equipment and clean out, resistent weed warnings, compatability, protectionof other crops and the environment, storage and disposal, safety and first aid, SDS’s available on request, and finally the conditions of sale which is a warranty and disclaimer all in one. Some labels refer to themselves as ‘instructions’ or ‘directions’ which is a bit too definitive. Others say guidelines or advice.  On one label under the heading, ‘General instructions’, it starts of by saying ‘as a general guide’………… Just plain information is the most apt!   Despite a few short cumings, the labels are the primary go to for information.   All the information you need is there, on the label.

However the final application will have a good measure of human judgement in the mix.

Jeff.

Additions.

17/3/24.   Labels are written so that a person with no experience, by following the label, can use the product safely and get a good result. The labels can’t take into account experience gained and so over time a persons interpretation of the label can change. to be continued.

 

More to explorer

Paraquat/ Diquat APVMA final review.

The APVMA, on the 23/6/26 approved the continued use of these products with added restrictions and handling requirments. There are two parts

Regulation changes

Flupropanate – permanent withholding. (on new labels) A slaughter withhold of  14 days on clean feed now applies if stock have grazed on

Safety Data Sheets

Unlike labels, SDS,s have no legal status. They can however be incorporated into other codes or standards.  When I first heard about