Unlike labels, SDS,s have no legal status. They can however be incorporated into other codes or standards. When I first heard about them, many years ago, the instructor explained that most of the information in SDS,s pertained to manufacturing & major storage and transport facilities and would not make much sense to end users. A similar remark was recently made by a current registrant. SDS,s are hazard based not risk based. If there is conflict between the SDS & the label, the label prevails. (APVMA )
Some of the big multi-nationals may write their own SDS but most registrants use consultants. They look at the customery data, trawl the internet for information and come up with a document anyone can request.
SDS’s often refer to Au/NZ standards for this or that. PPE for example. Au/NZ standards is a not for profit organization & has no legal status either. The suggestions they make are on a take it or leave it basis but can be adopted into other codes. This is what Safe Work Australia does. Codes of practice are not enforcable at law either. ( SWA website) However they can and are used in court as a standard to compare other practices to. You can use your own standard but it needs to be equal to or better than the standard, standard. ( not easy if something has gone pear shaped.)
SDS’s do follow in part, a uniform format, the global hazardous system. (GHS) The classifications, transport codes, composition, physical & chemical properties would be reliable enough. And yes, most of the information is about major facilities where people would not normally be reading labels. And yes, a lot of it is not understandable to an end user.
The hazards to health are preceded by words like, `may’or`possibly’ or `it is suggested’ but little is said about how or what to do about it. e.g. “This product may affect the unborn child”. Are we talking pre conception or post conception? Should the male or female avoid using it? Is the affect caused by ingestion, skin contact, inhalation or just by looking at it? When it come to end users the information on SDS,s vary considerably between tradenames for the same basic product.
Titan Paraquat. The drum & label signal heading is Dangerous Poison. Can kill if swallowed. The SDS however, tells us under the GHS criteria, Code H330, that it is fatal if inhaled. In fact it is repeated four times. But what about ingestion! Code H302, toxic if swallowed. May cause gastrointestinal irritation, diarrhoea and inflamation of the mouth, throat & oesophagus. The words death or fatal from ingestion is nowhere on the SDS. The SDS is seven pages long and you need to have a look at it to get the gist of these points. It ends with an absolute pearler of a disclaimer.
This SDS is prepared in accord with the Safe Work Australia document “Code of Practice for preparation of Safety data Sheets for hazardous Chemicals. Feb. 2016. The information contained in this safety data sheet is provided in good faith and is believed to be accurate at the date of issuance. Titan Ag. Pty.Ltd. makes no representation as to the accuarcy or the comprehensivness of the information and to the full extent allowed by law excludes all liability for any loss or damage related to supply or use of the information in this material safety data sheet. MSDS . COM.AU Pty.Ltd. ( the consultants who put it together), is not in a position to warrant the accuracy of the data herin. The user is cautioned to make their own determination as to the suitability of the information provided to the particular circumstance in which the product is used.”
( At least the above disclaimer confirms that it is the end user who determines how it is used.) J.n.
Two other Paraquat trade names had similar SDS,s. Copycats.
Not so Apparent Paraquat 250 All the GHS criteria is the same, so H302 harmfull if swallowed & H330 fatal if inhaled is in that section.
First Aid section. Ingestion. Rapid treatment is essential. Within 15 minutes if possible. It gives advice on treating on way to a doctor or hospital where they have specific guidelines for paraquat poisoning. Inhalation. If it is the vapour from the stenching agent, get into fresh air. If it is the spray mist, seek medical attention. Section 11 Toxicological information. If swallowed the L/D 50 is stated. 10 mls of the product could kill you. If a lethal dose is ingested you have about 48 hours. Inhalation. Highly toxic if inhaled but unlikely to be hazardous due to the low vapour pressure. The vapour comes from the stenching agent and smell does not mean the presence of Paraquat. Depending on the dose it may cause Pulonary Odema, which may be fatal. ( This is a ref. to spray mist.)
The disclaimer on this SDS is only a coupleof lines but in essence it’s ” all care and no responsibility”.
You need to look at these SDS.s youself because I’ve only pointed out the different perspectives of the two examples in relation to ingestion v inhalation.
Why is it then, that universely, these disowned SDS,s are the most flogged and policed documents that many of us have to contend with? To get contract work, ( gov. & autonomous bodies corporations etc.) you have agree to abide with them and if you get contract work you are audited to ensure that you are complying with them. PPE is a good example. What these auditors parrot on about is all rote! Never a word about Control of use Legislation which is the primary documentation for applicators. SDS,s are given significance in just about any agricultural QA program and again they, (the QA programs ) demonstrate a stunning lack of knowledge of Control of use legislation.
Jeff.
.